Hello dear
Welcome To Lost River Co-op & Cafe
Lost River Co-op & Cafe, located in the heart of Paoli, IN, is a delightful blend of community and fresh fare. This cozy eatery prides itself on offering housemade soups crafted from locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a taste of wholesome goodness in every bowl. The vibrant salad bar, featuring organic greens and rotating cold salads, allows patrons to customize their meals with fresh, seasonal produce. Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, making it a favorite pit stop for travelers and locals alike. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting lunch or a quick snack, Lost River Co-op is a treasure in small-town Indiana.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Small Soup of the Day
Salad Bar
Cold - Cut Sandwiches & Wraps
About
Lost River Co-op & Cafe
Welcome to the heart of Paoli, Indiana, where community meets culinary delight at the Lost River Co-op & Cafe. Nestled at 26 Library St, this charming co-op is not just a cafe, but a hub for fresh, locally sourced ingredients that celebrate the rich flavors of the region. With a mission to provide wholesome meals that nourish both the body and the community, the cafe stands as a testament to the charm of small-town America.
The menu is a delightful symphony of choices that cater to every palate. Each day, patrons can enjoy a Small Soup of the Day, crafted with love from housemade recipes utilizing locally sourced meats, eggs, and seasonal produce. Whether you choose the hearty meat option or the fresh vegetarian selection, you’re in for a treat that warms the soul. The salad bar offers a vibrant mix of organic greens and an assortment of six ever-changing cold salads—expect to find tantalizing options like fruit salad, pasta salad, and creamy bean salad, allowing guests to create their own unique garden plate.
What makes Lost River Co-op & Cafe truly special, however, is the warm and inviting atmosphere fostered by its dedicated staff. Patrons like Cathy Barfoot often rave about the friendly service and the immense pride the workers take in the products they offer. From morning coffee and muffins to organic groceries, you can feel the pride in each interaction. It's a place where you can not only grab a nourishing bite but also enjoy shopping for dairy, breads, fruits, vegetables, and meats from small local farms.
With cozy indoor and outdoor seating, Lost River Co-op & Cafe is the perfect spot to savor lunch while soaking in the local ambiance. Customers like Cortney Koch share their appreciation for the vibrant meals that never disappoint, making it a favorite for lunch breaks or leisurely afternoons.
As with all dining experiences, there are highs and lows. While many rave about the delicious sandwiches and inviting atmosphere, some, like Patricia Olsen, have noted inconsistencies, such as a watery soup lacking its usual charm. However, it’s this genuine feedback that the co-op embraces to continuously improve its offerings.
Whether you're on a road trip or simply exploring Paoli, Lost River Co-op & Cafe is a culinary treasure worth visiting. It's more than just a meal; it’s a slice of local life, where good food and good company come together beautifully.
For more information or to plan your visit, you can reach out at +1 812-723-3735. Dive into your next adventure at Lost River Co-op & Cafe—a place that embodies the spirit of community and the joys of fresh, local cuisine.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ I love stopping in the Lost River co-op when I am staying in town or just driving through. Whether Im grabbing a cup of coffee and muffin in the morning or a bag of groceries when I plan to stay for a bit. They carry dairy, breads, fruit, vegetables, and meats from small local farms. I am always happy with the service. The workers are friendly and just salt of the earth folks. What a treasure to have in small town Indiana. ”
“ It’s always very clean and always has a great selection. The staff is very nice and sweet. ”
“ This is our midway stop on the way to Bloomington from Louisville. Great food choices. The sandwiches were delicious. I'm not sure what happened to the soup. Usually, it's amazing, but it was watery and unappealing this time. ”
“ Awesome and original store. One gets not only fruits and vegetables and rare items, but also fresh, prepared food that can be eaten on site or taken home. Great place!!! ”
“ One of my favorite places to go when I visit Paoli! I always grab a nice lunch and some snacks, never a disappointment. I love that I can sit down and eat there if I want, indoor or outdoor seating. Staff are very friendly and helpful! ”
“ Have you checked out Lost River Market and Deli since the remodel?!? It’s spacious and inviting with even more healthy options including fresh, made to order sandwiches! Go see Gabe at the deli counter! I ordered the roast beef and cheddar on sourdough and it was delish! They also have outdoor seating and a brand new, private gathering space in the back! A must stop for anyone who wants a healthy option and friendly experience!! ”
“ Always a really solid option for healthier food and a good cafe space. They have high quality espresso drinks and a coffee bar now, which is a huge plus. Glad to see them reopen, its a must stop if you're coming through Paoli. ”
“ Truly special place in Paoli! Welcoming staff, delicious sandwiches and homemade soups. And a great selection of prepared foods, local meats, eggs and produce. I love the dill cucumber salad, cheesy potato soup and the chicken salad sandwich. The bulk spice wall is awesome! I buy all my spice refills here. Great place to grab lunch. ”